Scoring method

An almanac rates the moon.
We rate the water.

Every day gets a grade from A+ to F. Its condition assessment starts with the weighted factors that apply to the water you actually fish: 11 of them at any one spot, since tides count only on the coast and river flow only inland. Two are the moon’s, computed rather than measured, and together they carry 4% of that assessment.

The daily grade also reflects how much useful fishing time the day offers. With a substantially complete hourly forecast, we limit it by the strongest three-hour session and sustained favorable conditions. More good hours add flexibility with diminishing returns. The peak session is shown separately, and missing hours do not count as poor conditions. Water-temperature and measured oxygen limits apply to hourly recommendations too. A grade is a conditions index, not a catch probability.

A moon-phase almanac measures the other 96% not at all, and prints the same answer for every angler in the country.

What actually moves a grade

Weights come from peer-reviewed fisheries research, not from what anglers have always said. Nothing scores highly here on reputation alone.

There are two sets, because a trout stream and a tidal flat are not the same problem. Tides only exist on the coast, streamflow only exists inland. Everything else counts in both, and water temperature leads in both.

FreshwaterSaltwaterNot used for that water
Scoring weight of each factor, freshwater and saltwater
FactorWeight
Water tempFreshwater23%Saltwater22%
WindFreshwater12%Saltwater13%
TidesFreshwater–Saltwater12%
PrecipitationFreshwater8%Saltwater8%
StreamflowFreshwater8%Saltwater–
PressureFreshwater7%Saltwater7%
Air tempFreshwater6%Saltwater6%
Cloud coverFreshwater6%Saltwater6%
UV indexFreshwater5%Saltwater5%
SolunarFreshwater3%Saltwater3%
HumidityFreshwater3%Saltwater2%
Moon phaseFreshwater1%Saltwater1%

The two rows in amber are everything a moon-phase almanac can measure. They come to 4% of the model in fresh water and 4% in salt. These are raw weights, and they total 82 in fresh water and 85 on the coast, not 100. The engine averages over the weight actually in use, so a factor’s real share of a grade differs from its raw figure: somewhat larger as a rule, and moving with the season and with how well each input is known.

Eight things a printed table cannot tell you

Not because it is badly made. Because it is astronomy, and none of these are astronomical. Most of them move a grade on our side, sometimes by enough to call off the trip, and the ice changes the advice we give.

The lake is frozen

On a lake we can identify, we call it iced over when the last 30 days have been cold enough for a lake its size, and a big lake needs more cold than a pond. For walleye, northern pike, crappie, yellow perch, bluegill, and largemouth bass, ice then changes the grade. Wind, air temperature, humidity, UV and precipitation leave the score, because fish under a sealed surface feel none of them, and water temperature gives way to the share of its open-water catch rate each species keeps through the ice in Wisconsin's creel surveys, with first ice scored higher for walleye, crappie, and yellow perch. Other species, and a forecast with no species chosen, are still graded as open water with ice advice, and away from an identified lake a week of freezing weather changes the advice only. A calendar printed last autumn will still call it a best day.

A front arrives tomorrow

Pressure is scored on how fast it is changing across six hours as well as on its level, so a falling barometer shows up before the weather does. A printed table has no barometer.

The front already passed

The bluebird day, and the one people misread most often: clear, calm, cold-feeling, beautiful, and slow. Once pressure has climbed 4 mb off its recent low, or sits in a deep, clear high, we weigh how far it rose, how high it stands, how clear the sky is, and whether the wind has gone north-west or the temperature has dropped, to decide whether the day reads as post-frontal. When it does, the pressure factor takes a cut, the credit a post-rain clearing would otherwise earn stands down, and a species that minds fronts takes a penalty that fades over its recovery, which runs from 12 hours to 72 depending on the species. A calendar printed in advance cannot know a front came through, and the nicest-looking day of the week is often the one behind it.

A storm is due this afternoon

We read the forecast hour by hour. Thunder and the hour after it restrict recommendations. Sustained-wind restrictions rise from 20 mph to full exclusion at 25; gust restrictions rise from 30 to 39 mph. These are conservative recommendation rules, not official advisories or a guarantee of safety. A day hazardous throughout daylight grades no better than F. A partial-day storm removes affected windows, and losing useful hours can also lower the daily opportunity score.

The river is blown out

USGS discharge plus 48-hour rainfall separates a helpful post-rain bite from muddy water nobody should drive to.

The water is wrong for your fish

Water too warm for your species caps the whole grade, down to 35 at full confidence. The ceiling closes in gradually rather than all at once, because a fish one degree outside its comfort range is not in a different mood from one at the edge of it: it reaches 55 by 5°F past the limit and the full 35 by 10°F. Cold gets treated differently again, because it is different: a pike under the ice is still feeding, so for species with a winter fishery the cold ceiling only falls to 72. No lunar alignment overrides any of it.

Oxygen has crashed

Dissolved oxygen from the gauge, against per-species thresholds. Trout take a penalty below 9 mg/L, bass below 8, estuarine species below 6. Conservative score ceilings also restrict the daily grade and hourly recommendations when measured oxygen is low; favorable feeding bonuses cannot remove them. The ceilings change smoothly with the reading. Zero is a reading, not missing data. A weather-based oxygen estimate does not receive the authority of a measurement.

And where you are

Every item above is local. That is the one thing a single national calendar can never be.

The theory behind the tables

1926
Solunar theory

John Alden Knight compiled 33 factors thought to influence daily fish behavior, then discarded thirty of them. The three he kept were the sun, the moon and the tide.

Water temperature was not one of the three. A century of fisheries research has since put it first. The tables have not changed, because a table that measures nothing has nothing to update. It predates real-time river gauges, offshore buoys and satellite sea-surface temperature, and it works exactly as well without them.

Where the numbers come from

Public instrument networks, read live. No proprietary black box, and nothing hand-entered.

Data source for each scoring factor
FactorMeasured by
Water tempUSGS gauge, NOAA shore station or buoy, satellite SST, lake model
WindOpen-Meteo
TidesNOAA CO-OPS
PrecipitationOpen-Meteo
StreamflowUSGS discharge, Corps dam releases
PressureOpen-Meteo, level and rate of change
Air tempOpen-Meteo
Cloud coverOpen-Meteo
UV indexOpen-Meteo
SolunarComputed astronomy
HumidityOpen-Meteo, via vapor pressure deficit
Moon phaseComputed astronomy

Why the weights look like this

Every weight traces to published fisheries research. Where the evidence contradicts a popular angling belief, the evidence wins, even when that means scoring something lower than an angler expects.

Quigley et al. 2023

Ambient temperature was the only significant positive predictor of trout catch rate, and lunar phase showed no significant effect. Moon phase carries 1%.

Kuparinen 2010 · Hanson 2008 · Shaw 2021

Barometric pressure shows null or weak direct effects on catch rate. Pressure carries 7%, and is scored on its level and on how fast it is changing.

Corkum 2006

Water temperature dominates insect emergence, not humidity. Humidity carries 3% in fresh water and 2% in salt, and counts only in summer: the seasonal shifts take it to zero the rest of the year.

Lennox et al. 2017

Apparent wind-direction effects trace back to confounded weather patterns, so wind is scored on speed and consistency rather than compass heading.

Also drawn on: Stoner 2004, Vinson & Angradi 2014, Arlinghaus 2017. Moon-sign fishing, where water signs are supposed to be the best days, is folklore and carries no weight here. The zodiac sign is still displayed for readers who expect to see it, and contributes nothing to any grade.

What we will not claim

We publish national pages too, and they carry the same blind spot as anyone else’s. A country-wide calendar cannot know your water temperature. So our monthly almanac and weekly outlook publish a lunar rating, labeled as one, and they stop at B+. An A-grade day needs conditions only a real location can supply, and we will not print one without them.

The full A+ to F grade appears when you enter a location, and never before. Both kinds of calendar have limits. Only one of them tells you where they are.

See it applied to your water. Every factor above, graded for your spot.